As many of you are aware, Chris and I purchased a RV last year (feels weird saying that!! Welcome, 2015!) and we decided to do a ranking, point by point of what is different and better for each.
We'll start with the easy ones -
Overall size of cabin vs the motorhome - the cabin is about 190 sq feet, not including the balcony, whereas the motorhome is about 300 sq feet, but as we all know, the actual sq footage of space we can use on the cruise ship is significantly different (I mean, the RV has 2 TV's, but no pool or theater!) so cabin size is probably a good place to start. The bed is bigger in the cabin, the mattress is more comfortable, but there is no place to sit other than an uncomfortable couch. Less overall storage in the cabin though, and it's definitely going to be crowded when you have more than 2 people in the cabin. The bathrooms are pretty much a tie, the cabin has better storage and a better showerhead and water pressure, but the RV has more shelves. We also don't have any ice and the fridge is pretty crappy in the cabin, and the RV has a great fridge which can make ice! Advantage RV, but only because it's a complete living area.
Next, let's talk about food and beverages - the benefit of the cruise ship is it's all done for you, nothing to do but order what you want and someone will bring it to you with a smile, and take the dirty plates away when you are done. Nothing to cook or clean here! However, you do have to be wearing presentable clothes (no PJ's!) and there are sometimes when you just want a peanut butter and jelly sandwich and all that is available is roast beef. Advantage cruise ship, but not by much.
Ease of vacation - toss up really. Once on the cruise, it's pretty easy to get around, you don't have to spend a lot of time thinking about what you will eat and where you will go once you've made a choice on ship and itinerary. In the motorhome, you have to bring everything you want, and then make your own dinner or drinks - but you don't have to fly somewhere to get on the motorhome, just drive out and go.
Overall - I like both vacations - the RV is great for the ease of doing a weekend run, but requires a lot of prep and maintenance to execute. The cruise requires more money but somewhat less effort - I don't have to bring all my own food, but I have to get on an airplane to head someplace warm. Plus in the RV I can take the cats.
